In New York, the probate court is the Surrogate’s Court — a county-level court that supervises the transfer of a deceased person’s property, validates wills, appoints the people who will manage an estate, and resolves disputes among heirs and beneficiaries. Every county has one, and in Brooklyn it is the Kings County Surrogate’s Court. If someone dies owning assets in their sole name, the Surrogate’s Court is almost always where the legal cleanup begins.
I have spent a lot of years walking Brooklyn families through that courthouse, and the single most common thing I hear is some version of: “I didn’t know there even was a probate court.” There is, and understanding what it does — and what it does not do — saves grieving families months of confusion. This article lays out the court’s actual role under New York law, with particular attention to the messy situations that bring people to my office: contested estates and the awkward handoff that happens when a living person under guardianship dies and their matter has to migrate into probate.
What the Surrogate’s Court Actually Does
The Surrogate’s Court’s authority comes from the New York Constitution and is filled out by two main statutes: the Surrogate’s Court Procedure Act (SCPA), which governs procedure, and the Estates, Powers and Trusts Law (EPTL), which governs the substantive rights — who inherits, in what shares, and under what conditions. Think of the SCPA as the rulebook for how things happen in court and the EPTL as the rulebook for who gets what.
In practical terms, the court does a handful of distinct jobs:
- Admits wills to probate. The court examines whether a will is genuine, properly executed, and made by someone with capacity and free of undue influence. Only after the will is “admitted” does it have legal force.
- Appoints fiduciaries. It issues “letters testamentary” to an executor named in a will, or “letters of administration” to an administrator when there is no will. Without those letters, no one has legal authority to touch the assets — banks and brokerages will not release a dime.
- Supervises estate administration. Creditors get paid, taxes get filed, and what is left is distributed. The court can require accountings and step in when a fiduciary misbehaves.
- Resolves disputes. Will contests, claims by creditors, fights between co-executors, and challenges to a fiduciary’s accounting are all litigated here.
- Protects vulnerable parties. The court appoints guardians ad litem for minors and incapacitated persons whose interests are at stake in a proceeding.
One clarification worth making early: not every estate goes through full, formal probate. New York offers lighter procedures for modest estates, which I cover below. But when there is a will, real property, a meaningful bank balance, or a family disagreement, the Surrogate’s Court is where it lands.
Probate vs. Administration: Two Doors Into the Same Court
The path through Surrogate’s Court depends on whether the person left a valid will.
When there is a will: probate
The person named as executor files the original will with a probate petition in the county where the decedent lived. The court notifies the “distributees” — the relatives who would have inherited under the intestacy rules if there were no will — and gives them a chance to object. If no one contests, and the will checks out, the court admits it and issues letters testamentary. The executor then carries out the will’s instructions under the court’s supervision. This is governed primarily by SCPA Article 14.
When there is no will: administration
If someone dies “intestate” — without a will — there is nothing to admit. Instead, a relative petitions for letters of administration under SCPA Article 10, and the estate is distributed according to the intestacy formula in EPTL 4-1.1. That statute sets a strict order: a surviving spouse and children share first (the spouse takes the first $50,000 plus half the balance, with the children splitting the rest), then more distant relatives if there is no spouse or descendants. The decedent’s wishes, if they were ever expressed informally, are irrelevant — the statute controls.
The distinction matters because intestacy frequently produces results families never intended. A common Brooklyn scenario: an unmarried partner of twenty years inherits nothing, because EPTL 4-1.1 does not recognize unmarried partners at all. The court cannot fix that. It applies the law as written, which is exactly why having a properly drafted will — or a comprehensive will reviewed by counsel — matters so much.
The Spousal Right of Election: A Floor the Court Enforces
New York gives a surviving spouse a protection that overrides a will: the right of election under EPTL 5-1.1-A. A surviving spouse is entitled to claim the greater of $50,000 or one-third of the net estate, regardless of what the will says — even if the will leaves the spouse nothing. The right also reaches certain assets that pass outside the will, called “testamentary substitutes,” such as jointly held accounts and certain transfers made during the marriage, so a spouse cannot be disinherited by simply moving everything into joint names.
The election is not automatic. The spouse must serve and file it within six months of the fiduciary’s appointment, and no later than two years after death. Miss the window and the right can be lost. The Surrogate’s Court is where the election is filed and where disputes over its validity and reach are decided. I raise this often because spouses who feel shortchanged by a will frequently do not realize the law already hands them a one-third floor — they just have to claim it on time.
Small and Modest Estates: When Full Probate Is Overkill
Not every death requires the full machinery. SCPA Article 13 provides a streamlined “small estate” or voluntary administration procedure for estates where the personal property (excluding real estate that passes by other means) is worth $50,000 or less. Instead of a formal proceeding, a “voluntary administrator” files an affidavit, and the court issues a certificate that lets them collect and distribute the assets. It is faster, cheaper, and far less paperwork.
This procedure is a quiet workhorse. For a parent who left a single modest bank account and a few belongings, Article 13 can resolve the entire matter in weeks rather than the many months a full probate can take. The catch is the dollar limit and the exclusion of certain assets — if there is real property to convey or the numbers run higher, you are back in full probate or administration. A short consultation usually tells you which door applies. You can reach our office through our contact page if you are unsure which path fits your situation.
What the Probate Court Does Not Touch
A surprising amount of property never goes through Surrogate’s Court at all, because it passes outside the estate by operation of law. Understanding this prevents a lot of needless litigation. Generally outside probate:
- Assets in a revocable living trust. Property a person transferred into a properly funded revocable living trust during life passes to beneficiaries under the trust’s terms, without court involvement. Avoiding probate is one of the main reasons New Yorkers use these trusts.
- Jointly owned property with rights of survivorship. A joint bank account or a home held as joint tenants typically passes automatically to the survivor.
- Accounts with named beneficiaries. Life insurance, retirement accounts, and “payable-on-death” accounts go straight to the named beneficiary.
Two related documents also stop working at death and are therefore not probate matters, though families routinely confuse them. A statutory durable power of attorney under General Obligations Law 5-1501 lets an agent manage finances while the principal is alive but becomes void the instant the principal dies — at that point only a court-appointed fiduciary has authority. Likewise, a health care proxy governs medical decisions during life and has no role after death. I mention these because relatives frequently arrive at the bank waving a power of attorney, only to learn it expired the moment their loved one passed.
Contested Estates: When the Court Becomes a Battleground
Most of the probate work that ends up genuinely adversarial falls into a few categories, and the Surrogate’s Court has tools for each.
The classic fight is the will contest. An interested party — usually a disinherited child or a distributee who would have done better under intestacy — files objections challenging the will on grounds such as improper execution, lack of testamentary capacity, fraud, or undue influence. Before objections are filed, parties have a right under SCPA 1404 to examine the attorney who drafted the will and the witnesses, which often determines whether a contest is worth pursuing. These are evidence-heavy proceedings, and the burden shifts depending on the ground asserted.
Beyond will contests, the court hears accounting disputes, where beneficiaries challenge how a fiduciary handled the money, and proceedings to remove a fiduciary who has breached their duties or has a disqualifying conflict. For a fuller picture of where these conflicts tend to erupt, this overview of the common challenges faced during the probate process is a useful companion read.
From Guardianship to Probate: A Transition the Court Must Manage
Here is a situation that catches families off guard, and one I see constantly. Suppose an elderly Brooklyn resident was placed under a guardianship during life — often a Mental Hygiene Law Article 81 guardianship — because they could no longer manage their own affairs. A guardian was appointed, controlled the finances, made the decisions. Then the person dies.
The guardian’s authority ends at death, just like a power of attorney’s. The estate now belongs to a different court and a different fiduciary. This handoff is more delicate than it sounds. The guardian must render a final accounting, and the assets that were under guardianship control have to be turned over to whoever the Surrogate’s Court appoints as executor or administrator. When the same family members were fighting during the guardianship — and they very often were — those fights migrate straight into the probate proceeding. Old accusations about how the guardian spent money resurface as objections to the guardian’s final accounting and as ammunition in the will contest.
Managing that transition well requires someone who understands both sides of the bridge: the guardianship that is ending and the probate that is beginning. The accounting from the guardianship period and the inventory that opens the estate need to line up, or the discrepancies become the next round of litigation. Families who treat the death as a clean reset are usually unpleasantly surprised. For estate administration matters specifically, our firm works alongside Morgan Legal’s team on NYC probate and estate administration, and families with assets in more than one state sometimes also coordinate with their Florida probate counterparts when a snowbird parent leaves property down south.
How Long Does It Take, and What Does the Court Expect of You?
An uncontested Brooklyn probate, with cooperative heirs and clean paperwork, often takes somewhere between seven months and a year from filing to distribution — partly because creditors must be given time to come forward and tax matters must clear. A contested estate can run for years. The court does not move faster because a family is in a hurry; it moves at the pace the SCPA’s deadlines and notice requirements allow.
What the court expects from a fiduciary is fidelity and documentation. Keep every receipt, do not commingle estate money with your own, pay creditors before beneficiaries, and account honestly. Fiduciaries who improvise tend to end up explaining themselves under oath. If you have been named executor and feel out of your depth, that instinct is correct — and it is exactly the moment to get counsel involved before you make a move you cannot undo. You can learn more about how we handle these matters on our probate practice page.
The Bottom Line
The Surrogate’s Court is not an obstacle; it is the mechanism New York uses to make sure a deceased person’s property reaches the right hands, that creditors and spouses get their statutory due, and that disputes are resolved by a neutral judge rather than around a kitchen table. For most Brooklyn families the process is orderly and survivable. For families coming out of a contested guardianship, the stakes and the friction are higher — but the court is built to handle exactly that handoff, provided the people involved understand the rules and respect the deadlines.
Frequently Asked Questions
What court handles probate in Brooklyn, New York?
Probate in Brooklyn is handled by the Kings County Surrogate’s Court. Every New York county has its own Surrogate’s Court, and you file in the county where the deceased person was domiciled at death. The court admits wills, appoints executors and administrators, supervises estate administration, and resolves disputes such as will contests and accounting challenges.
Do all estates have to go through probate in New York?
No. Assets in a revocable living trust, jointly owned property with rights of survivorship, and accounts with named beneficiaries (like life insurance and retirement accounts) pass outside probate. In addition, estates with $50,000 or less in personal property can often use the simplified small-estate (voluntary administration) procedure under SCPA Article 13 instead of full probate.
Can a surviving spouse be completely disinherited in New York?
Generally no. Under the right of election in EPTL 5-1.1-A, a surviving spouse can claim the greater of $50,000 or one-third of the net estate even if the will leaves them nothing, and the right reaches certain assets that pass outside the will. The spouse must file the election on time — within six months of the fiduciary’s appointment and no later than two years after death.
What happens to a guardianship when the protected person dies?
The guardian’s authority ends at death. The guardian must file a final accounting, and control of the assets transfers to the executor or administrator appointed by the Surrogate’s Court. This guardianship-to-probate handoff often reignites family disputes, because objections to the guardian’s accounting and challenges to the will tend to overlap. Coordinating the two proceedings carefully helps avoid a second round of litigation.
How long does probate take in New York?
An uncontested probate with cooperative heirs typically takes about seven months to a year from filing to final distribution, largely because creditors must be given time to come forward and tax matters must clear. Contested estates involving will challenges or fiduciary disputes can take several years.
Have a question about your estate?
Talk it through with Russel Morgan — free 30-minute consult.